Keep it either wii, ps3, 360, or PC 2005-2013. My top 5 fav games of last gen are (in no order):

Dark Souls: possibly the best game i have ever played. Easily top 3 ever

Xcom: Enemy Within: Incredible and thrilling strategy with good gameplay progression

Red Dead Redemption: almost flawless

Super Mario Galaxy 2: Platforming masterpiece

The Last of Us (beats Uncharted 2 by a hair): Unforgettable experience that comes once in a decade

What are yours and why?